I roasted a chicken! I know, amazing. And it turned out fabulously. It was juicy, but cooked all the way through, and the meat was practically falling off the bone. Here's a helpful tip: A roaster chicken is about twice as big as a fryer chicken, which is the size that this recipe calls for. Confusing, but true. This recipe is from How to Cook Everything, and it's actually part of recipe with more variations. I'm just going to tell you what I did, and if you want the other variations, tell me, and I'll know what to get you for Christmas.
Makes 4 servings
Time: About 1 hour
We justifiably associate roast chicken with elegance, but it can also be super weeknight food, cooked in just about an hour. This method works because the high heat provided by the heated skillet cooks the thighs faster than the breasts, which are exposed only to the heat of the oven. It gives you nice browning without drying out the breast meat, and it's easily varied. If at any point during the cooking the pan juices begin to smoke, just add a little water or wine (white or red, your choice) to the pan. This will reduce browning, however, so don't do it unless you must. I suggest serving the pan juices with the chicken (you can call it sauce naturel if you like).
- 1 whole chicken, 3 to 4 pounds, trimmed of excess fat
- 3 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil
- 1 tablespoon good smoked or sweet paprika
- Salt and freshly ground black pepper
- A few sprigs fresh tarragon, rosemary, or thyme (optional)
- 5 or 6 cloves garlic, peeled (optional)
- Chopped fresh herbs for garnish
[this is Katie here: before starting this process, I decided I wanted to brine the chicken. Bittman doesn't actually recommend brining smaller poultry, so a few hours before I rubbed it down pretty well with a combo of coarse salt (it has to be coarse), minced garlic, and some herb or another, I can't remember. Tarragon maybe. Then I put it back in the fridge on a plate. When I was ready to cook, I rinsed the chicken off really well and patted it dry. Now this is important: if you do this,
do not salt the chicken when you put it in the oven. Wait until you cut it up to serve it and see if it needs salt then, or just put some salt on the table. I didn't think it needed any more salt.]
1. Heat the oven to 450°F. Five minutes after turning on the oven, put a cast-iron or other heavy ovenproof skillet on a rack set low in the oven. Rub the chicken with the olive oil mixed with the paprika, sprinkle it with salt and pepper, and put the herb sprigs on it if you're using them. [KV: I didn't]
2. When both oven and pan are hot, 10 or 15 minutes later, carefully put the chicken, breast side up, in the hot skillet; if you're using garlic, scatter it around the bird. Roast, undisturbed, for 40 to 50 minutes or until an instant-read thermometer inserted in the meaty part of the thigh registers 155–165°F. 3. Tip the pan to let the juices from the bird's cavity flow into the pan (if they are red, cook for another 5 minutes). Transfer the bird to a platter and let it rest; if you like, pour the pan juices into a clear measuring cup, then pour or spoon off some of the fat. Reheat the juices if necessary, quarter the bird, garnish, and serve with the pan juices.
Results:
The only problem, it turns out, is that neither of us like drumsticks. Well, actually, I thought they were delicious right out of the oven, but dark meat leftovers are pretty meh, at best. So I don't know how often I'll roast a chicken, unless it's for a crowd of more than two people, and some of those people are happy to pass on white meat in favor of dark.